Our Menu
Free bottle of wine: dine in at Papa's and spend $50.00 or more in the market on the same day and receive a free bottle of Papa's vino (*Not valid with other offers).
Sum Dis, Sum Dat
Bimini Bread
$8.00
Served with cinnamon butter.
Conch Chowder (Red)
$9.00
Bahamian style - since 1976
Clam Chowder (White)
$8.00
New England style.
Edamame
$8.00/+
Salted $8.00 | Sweet Chili $9.00
Queso Dip
$12.00
Served with wonton chips and pico.
Chicken Fingers
$12.00
Beer battered to perfection.
Fried Calamari
$14.00
Served with our signature dynamite sauce.
Stonie Rangoons
$13.00
Served with sweet chili sauce.
Panko Fried Wahoo Bites
$17.00
Drizzled with eel sauce and spicy mayo.
Conch Fritters
$16.00
Served with Island slaw and island sauce.
Sweet Chili or Dynamite Shrimp
$16.00
Beer battered and tossed in sauce.
Smoked Fish Dip
$16.00
Served with crudite and flatbread crackers.
Wahoo Dip
$15.00
Simply delicious.
Blackened Sword Bites
$19.00
Served with seaweed salad.
Fried Cracked Conch
$23.00
Beer battered conch with island sauce.
Fried Lobster Bites
$26.00
Beer battered lobster bites with spicy mayo.
Seafood Vinaigrette
$17.00
Papa's Bahamian ceviche made with conch, crawfish, shrimp, tomatoes, onions, celery, and olives.
Raw Bar
Oysters Shooters
$5.00/+
Beer $5.00 | Vodka $7.00 • Get the party started, you want...
Oysters On The Half Shell
$18.00/Half Dozen
Nola Oysters
$20.00
Char-grilled with parmesan cheese.
Black & Blues
$20.00
Char grilled with bacon and blue cheese.
Oysters Rockefeller
$21.00
Creamed spinach and parmesan cheese.
Clams On The Half Shell
$8.00/Half Dozen
Steamed Clams with Crustini
$15.00
Peel & Eats
$16.00
Steamed and tossed in old bay butter.
Alaskan King Crab
MP
Snow Crab
MP
On The Bun
Served with lettuce & tomato | Pickle Spear | American, Swiss +$1.00 | Bacon +2.00
Dry - Aged Burger
$15.00
Brisket, short rib and dry aged strip blend.
The Klee Burger
$18.00
Burger topped with fried onions, bacon, crumbled blue cheese, and buffalo sauce.
The Shrimp Burger
$18.00
Fresh Catch Sandwich
MP
Fried Conch
$25.00
Lobster
$28.00
Tacos & Quesadillas
3 tacos served on soft flour tortillas with cabbage, pico, and chipotle mayo | Upgrade to a signature style (tacos only).
Chicken
$15.00
Steak
$18.00
Shrimp
$17.00
Conch
$25.00
Pork Belly
$18.00
Fresh Catch
MP
Lobster
$28.00
Big Juicy Po Boy's
Fresh Catch
MP
Shrimp
$18.00
Pork Belly
$18.00
Dynamite
$2.00
Lettuce, house dynamite sauce.
Matt's Way
$3.00
Lettuce, avocado, bacon, and yum yum.
Grimaldi's Gringo
$3.00
Lettuce, queso, pico, and avocado.
Fast Eddie's Fried Rice
Onion, carrot, egg, garlic, scallion, and hibachi sauce | Add Hibachi Veg +$4.00
Chicken
$23.00
Shrimp
$25.00
Rib - Eye Steak
$28.00
Fresh Catch
MP
Conch
$30.00
Swordfish
$30.00
Pork Belly
$25.00
Scallops
$30.00
Lobster
$32.00
Seafood World Classics
Caesar Salad
$12.00
Croutons, parmesan, bacon, romaine, and Caesar dressing | Add your choice of protein MP.
Fish & Chips
MP
Fresh Catch & a Side
MP
Garnished with broccoli, blackened, grilled, beer battered or panko fried.
Snapper Franciase
MP
Served over linguine with broccoli.
Linguine & Clams
$20.00
White wine sauce and toast points.
Lobster Mac & Cheese
MP
House mac and cheese tossed with fresh lobster.
Whole Fried Fish
MP
Served with island slaw and your choice of sauce.
Sugarshack
Key Lime Pie
$10.00
Stoned Brownie
$12.00
Deep-fried served with ice cream.
Stone Crab Claws
Stone Crab Claws
MP | Seasonal
Served with Papa's stonie sauce fresh from our boats to your table. Ask your server for availability and sizes.
Sushi Bar
Not Your Ordinary Ceviche
$21.00
Choose your catch & pick your style: salmon, conch, tuna, wahoo, or yellowtail | Papa's peruvian style or wahoo style.
Thai Salad
$25.00
Choose from wahoo, salmon, tuna, or beef. Chopped romaine, cucumber, tomato, avocado, asparagus, seaweed salad, ginger, and Japanese dressing.
Won - Tom's Tuna Nachos
$21.00
Each chip gets treated equally.
Pauly's Poke Bowl
$23.00
Tuna, wahoo, salmon, mango, avocado, masago, wahooo sauce, wasabi mayo, and cucumber | Make it a sushi bowl - add White or Brown Rice +$2.00
Mack's Tuna Tatake
$21.00
Sliced tuna, wahooo sauce, masago, seaweed salad, ginger, and wasabi.
Papa's Tuna Yukke
$21.00
Served with cucumber chips, flatbreads, or wonton chips.
Carpaccio
$21.00
Torched Pacific yellowtail, sea salt, cilantro, ponzu sauce, lime, and jalapeno.
Crispy Rice Cakes
$18.00
Spicy tuna with crispy garlic chili oil, avocado, eel sauce, and cilantro.
Hand Rolls
Add Sum Greens (Avocado or Cucumber) +$1.00 | Sub with Brown Rice +$2.00 | Sub Soy Paper +$2.00
Spicy Crab
$6.00
Spicy Salmon
$7.00
Spicy Tuna
$8.00
Spicy Wahoo
$8.00
Spicy Conch
$8.00
Spicy Yellowtail
$9.00
Sushi or Sashimi
With or Without Rice.
Salmon
$4.00
Conch
$4.00
Eel
$4.00
Wahoo
$5.00
Tuna
$5.00
Yellowtail
$5.00
Local Inspired Rolls
Bomb sauces: Spicy Mayo, Eel Sauce, Kimchi Sauce.
Sir' Reel California Roll
$17.00
Spicy lump crabmeat, avocado, cucumber topped with sesame seeds, crunchy flakes, and spicy mayo.
Summer Breeze
$19.00
Shrimp tempura, cream cheese, avocado, asparagus, pineapple topped with strawberry, wrapped in soy paper, avocado, masago, sesame seed, and bomb sauces.
Mama Fuma Roll
$28.00
Spicy lump crabmeat, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, topped with salmon, tuna, yellowtail, masago, sesame seeds, and bomb sauces.
Volcano Roll
$21.00
Conch or Scallop, avocado, cream cheese, cucumber, topped with conch and Japanese mayo, masago, sesame seeds, and eel sauce.
Bimini Twist
$23.00
Cracked conch, avocado, asparagus, cilantro, cream cheese, jalapeno, topped with spicy tuna, sesame seeds, masago, bomb sauce, and crunchy flakes.
Sex On The Grass
$18.00
Shrimp tempura, asparagus, avocado topped with wahoo, masago, sesame seeds, and bomb sauces.
Firecracker Roll
$21.00
Shrimp tempura, avocado, cream cheese, topped with salmon, spicy crab, masago, sesame seeds, firecracker sauce, and eel sauce.
Yellow Dragon Roll
$18.00
Shrimp tempura, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, topped with salmon, masago, sesame seeds, and bomb sauces.
Queen Bee's Red Dragon
$21.00
Shrimp tempura, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, topped with tuna, masago, sesame seeds, and bomb sauces.
Yoga Joint Roll
$25.00
Shrimp tempura, avocado, cucumber, topped with honey seared scallops, masago, eel sauce, and spicy mayo | Swap Out Shrimp for Wahoo +$2.00
Santiso Roll
$28.00
Beer battered wahoo, spicy lump crabmeat, asparagus, avocado, topped with spicy tuna, jalapeno, masago, sesame seeds, crunchy flakes, and bomb sauces.
Ceviche Roll
$28.00
Yellowtail, red onion, avocado, cucumber, mango tossed ceviche style, wrapped in soy paper, topped with masago, jalapeno, and cilantro. Served with a side of wahoo sauce.
Reel Buttered Crab Roll
$21.00
Lump crab meat wrapped in soy paper ponzu sauce, a side of melted butter.
Connected by Water Roll
$23.00
Salmon, tuna, wahoo, avocado, cream cheese, cucumber, seaweed salad, topped with masago, sesame seeds, and kimchi sauce.
Zach Attack #54
$25.00
Shrimp tempura, spicy tuna, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, topped with salmon, masago, sesame seeds, crunchy flakes, and bomb sauces.
The Tod Roy Roll
$25.00
Shrimp tempura, spicy lump crabmeat, avocado, asparagus, cream cheese, topped with salmon, jalapeno, masago, sesame seeds, crunchy flakes, and bomb sauces.
Lobster Bomb
$34.00
Lobster tempura, avocado, cucumber, lettuce, topped with masago, sesame seeds, bomb sauces, served with panko crusted lobster bites.
Tekeze Roll
$25.00
Tempura wahoo, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, seaweed salad, topped with tuna masago, sesame seeds, and bomb sauces.
Tabo Wabo Roll
$18.00
Wahoo, avocado, cucumber, topped with salmon, masago, sesame seeds, and bomb sauces.
The Pelagic Roll
$25.00
Spicy tuna, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, pineapple, seaweed salad, topped with wahoo, jalapeno, masago, sesame seeds, and dynamite sauce.
O - Sea - D Roll
$25.00
Tuna, avocado, cucumber, mango, topped with wahoo, jalapeno, masago, sesame seeds, tempura flakes, and wahoo sauce.
Spicy Diva Roll
$23.00
Spicy yellowtail, avocado, cilantro, cucumber, mango, jalapeno, masago, topped with masago and sesame seeds.
Red Stone Roll
$30.00
Lobster tempura, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, topped with spicy tuna, mango, masago, sesame seeds, crunchy flakes, and bomb sauces.
Cove Roll
$30.00
King crab, kewpie mayo, masago, crispy tempura, cucumber, topped with seared tuna and salmon with black pepper truffle butter, and tempura salmon skin.
Classic Rolls
Tempura Roll
$15.00
Shrimp or Wahoo tempura, asparagus, avocado, cream cheese, sesame seeds, eel sauce, and spicy mayo.
Eel Express Roll
$15.00
Baked eel, avocado, cream cheese, cucumber, topped with eel sauce and sesame seeds.
Spicy Roll
$15.00
Spicy tuna or wahoo, avocado, and cucumber.
Cartel Roll
$15.00
Half and half, spicy tuna, spicy wahoo, avocado, and cucumber.
Yom Kippur Roll
$15.00
Salmon, avocado, cream cheese, cucumber, masago, and sesame seeds.
Sexy Mama Rolls
Rolling without the rice | *Low crab friends, we use a touch of rice to hold the ends of the rolls together.
Bikini Mama Roll
$23.00
Tuna, avocado, cucumber, jalapeno, mango, strawberry, rolled in soy paper.
Miss Hibiscus Roll
$23.00
Avocado, masago, seaweed salad, salmon, tuna, and wahoo, drizzled with eel sauce, spicy wasabi mayo, and crunchy flakes rolled in soy paper.
Cassie Roll
$23.00
Salmon, tuna, yellowtail, asparagus, avocado cream cheese, and masago, wrapped in seaweed | Make it sassy - Sub Soy Paper +$2.00
Victoria's No Secret
$23.00
Shrimp tempura, spicy lump crabmeat, asparagus, avocado, seaweed salad, and spicy mayo rolled in soy paper.
The Kitty Kat
$25.00
Spicy lump crabmeat, tuna, wahoo, asparagus, avocado, seaweed salad, and topped with wahoo sauce rolled in soy paper.
Bombchelle Roll
$23.00
Tuna, wahoo, avocado, cream cheese, cucumber, jalapeno, pineapple, and seaweed salad rolled in seaweed topped with spicy mayo.
Sunshine Roll
$23.00
Tuna, salmon, crab, and avocado, wrapped in cucumber with ponzu sauce.
Payin'it Forward
Our family business is built on relationships and service. Join us each month as we raise funds and awareness for families and foundations close to our hearts. Look out for our monthly fundraiser, Pelagic Nights. Purchase one of these rolls and round up when you check out to pay it forward. *Portions of the proceeds from these rolls will go to their designated foundations/causes: Fro Pro Foundation | Mission Fishin' | Pelagic Nights Christmas Project
Fropro Roll
$17.00
Asparagus, avocado, beets, cucumber, jalapeño, and mango rolled with brown rice, drizzled with eel sauce.
Mission Fishin' Roll
$30.00
Himachi, kewpie mayo, and crispy garlic chili oil cucumber, topped with seared hamachi wasabi mayo, jalapeños, mushrooms, summer truffle sauce, and scallions.
Tony D's 'pay It Forward' Roll
$25.00
Yellowtail, scallion, cucumber, and cream cheese topped with wahoo, jalapeño, and masago drizzled with kimchee sauce.
Sides
Side Salad
$5.00
Island Slaw
$5.00
French Fries
$5.00
Truffle Fries
$8.00
Hibachi Veg
$5.00
Steamed Broccoli
$5.00
Mac & Cheese
$6.00