Our Menu
Free bottle of wine: dine in at Papa's and spend $50.00 or more in the market on the same day and receive a free bottle of Papa's vino (*Not valid with other offers).
Sum Dis, Sum Dat
Bimini Bread
Conch Chowder (Red)
Clam Chowder (White)
Edamame
Queso Dip
Chicken Fingers
Fried Calamari
Stonie Rangoons
Panko Fried Wahoo Bites
Conch Fritters
Sweet Chili or Dynamite Shrimp
Smoked Fish Dip
Wahoo Dip
Blackened Sword Bites
Fried Cracked Conch
Fried Lobster Bites
Seafood Vinaigrette
Raw Bar
Oysters Shooters
Oysters On The Half Shell
Nola Oysters
Black & Blues
Oysters Rockefeller
Clams On The Half Shell
Steamed Clams with Crustini
Peel & Eats
Alaskan King Crab
Snow Crab
On The Bun
Served with lettuce & tomato | Pickle Spear | American, Swiss +$1.00 | Bacon +2.00
Dry - Aged Burger
The Klee Burger
The Shrimp Burger
Fresh Catch Sandwich
Fried Conch
Lobster
Tacos & Quesadillas
3 tacos served on soft flour tortillas with cabbage, pico, and chipotle mayo | Upgrade to a signature style (tacos only).
Chicken
Steak
Shrimp
Conch
Pork Belly
Fresh Catch
Lobster
Big Juicy Po Boy's
Fresh Catch
Shrimp
Pork Belly
Dynamite
Matt's Way
Grimaldi's Gringo
Fast Eddie's Fried Rice
Onion, carrot, egg, garlic, scallion, and hibachi sauce | Add Hibachi Veg +$4.00
Chicken
Shrimp
Rib - Eye Steak
Fresh Catch
Conch
Swordfish
Pork Belly
Scallops
Lobster
Seafood World Classics
Caesar Salad
Fish & Chips
Fresh Catch & a Side
Snapper Franciase
Linguine & Clams
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Whole Fried Fish
Sugarshack
Key Lime Pie
Stoned Brownie
Stone Crab Claws
Stone Crab Claws
Sushi Bar
Not Your Ordinary Ceviche
Thai Salad
Won - Tom's Tuna Nachos
Pauly's Poke Bowl
Mack's Tuna Tatake
Papa's Tuna Yukke
Carpaccio
Crispy Rice Cakes
Hand Rolls
Add Sum Greens (Avocado or Cucumber) +$1.00 | Sub with Brown Rice +$2.00 | Sub Soy Paper +$2.00
Spicy Crab
Spicy Salmon
Spicy Tuna
Spicy Wahoo
Spicy Conch
Spicy Yellowtail
Sushi or Sashimi
With or Without Rice.
Salmon
Conch
Eel
Wahoo
Tuna
Yellowtail
Local Inspired Rolls
Bomb sauces: Spicy Mayo, Eel Sauce, Kimchi Sauce.
Sir' Reel California Roll
Summer Breeze
Mama Fuma Roll
Volcano Roll
Bimini Twist
Sex On The Grass
Firecracker Roll
Yellow Dragon Roll
Queen Bee's Red Dragon
Yoga Joint Roll
Santiso Roll
Ceviche Roll
Reel Buttered Crab Roll
Connected by Water Roll
Zach Attack #54
The Tod Roy Roll
Lobster Bomb
Tekeze Roll
Tabo Wabo Roll
The Pelagic Roll
O - Sea - D Roll
Spicy Diva Roll
Red Stone Roll
Cove Roll
Classic Rolls
Tempura Roll
Eel Express Roll
Spicy Roll
Cartel Roll
Yom Kippur Roll
Sexy Mama Rolls
Rolling without the rice | *Low crab friends, we use a touch of rice to hold the ends of the rolls together.
Bikini Mama Roll
Miss Hibiscus Roll
Cassie Roll
Victoria's No Secret
The Kitty Kat
Bombchelle Roll
Sunshine Roll
Payin'it Forward
Our family business is built on relationships and service. Join us each month as we raise funds and awareness for families and foundations close to our hearts. Look out for our monthly fundraiser, Pelagic Nights. Purchase one of these rolls and round up when you check out to pay it forward. *Portions of the proceeds from these rolls will go to their designated foundations/causes: Fro Pro Foundation | Mission Fishin' | Pelagic Nights Christmas Project
Fropro Roll
Mission Fishin' Roll
Tony D's 'pay It Forward' Roll
Sides
Side Salad
Island Slaw
French Fries
Truffle Fries
Hibachi Veg
Steamed Broccoli
Mac & Cheese
All platters must be paid for in advance | No refunds 24 hours prior to pick up
Party Platters / Trays
Half pan feed approx 15, full pan approx. 30 people.
Panko Chicken Fingers
Chicken Satay
Queso Fiesta
Smoked Fish Dip
Wahoo Dip
Sesame Seared Tuna
Shrimp Cocktail
Peel & Eat Shrimp
Blackened Swordfish Bites
Stone Crab Claws (When Available)
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Maine Lobster
Lobster
King Crab
Stoned Crab Dip
Filet Mignon Sliders
Hibachi Trays
Hibachi served a la carte in aluminum catering pans | Served with Yum Yum sauce | Extra Yum Yum Sauce +$8.00/per pint | Half pan feed approx 15, full pan approx. 30 people.
Hibachi Fried Rice
Veggies
HIBACHI PROTEINS:
Chicken
Steak
Shrimp
Scallops
Lobster
Sushi Boats
Sushi boats are priced per roll and come with soy sauce, spicy mayo, eel sauce & chopsticks | Boats must be returned within 3 business days or a $200.00 boat fee will be incurred | All sushi rolls served on boats will be inside out (rice on outside).